I had a big crush on this influencer girl from Dallas. She’s super pretty, posts lots of dance videos, and I messaged her many times but she never replied. She always made videos with her roommate, who looked okay but nothing special. So I thought maybe I could get close to the roommate, become friends, and somehow reach the influencer. That was my big plan. But something crazy happened. I started hanging out with the roommate and we actually connected.
She was fun, kind, and real. We started dating, and every weekend we went to parties and had a great time. The influencer also had a good opinion of me because my girlfriend used to talk about me to her. Then one night, both girls were drunk. Me and my girlfriend went to our bedroom, had sex, and she fell into deep sleep. In the middle of the night, I woke up to use the restroom and saw the influencer sitting alone in the living room, crying. I was confused and asked what was going on.
She started talking and said, “I’ve never had someone like you. My friend told me how nice and good you are. Even though she’s not that pretty, she still got a great boyfriend like you.” Then she asked, “Can we at least kiss?” One thing led to another, and we ended up having sex. They both didn’t know about each other. The next morning, I was sitting in the living room and both girls came to me one after the other, treating me like a king. After a while, they both sat next to me and started getting suspicious.
After all the drama, they argued at first, but somehow things calmed down. One night, we were playing a “Let’s Get Deep” card game, and the first card said “threesome.” We all laughed, but then it actually happened. That first time felt like I was in heaven. For a few weeks, it continued like that wild, fun, and no problems. But now things have changed. Both of them are asking me to choose who I really want. The roommate is sweet and truly cares about me. The influencer is the one I always dreamed of. My mind says pick the good girl, but my heart still wants the influencer.
And honestly, I still want both. I even searched which religion allows two wives. I know it sounds crazy, but I’m stuck. Did I settle too early, or am I just being greedy? I really don’t know what to do. Help me out.